Scottish civil justice reforms to change the claims landscape
Scottish civil justice reforms are likely to increase claims spend and defence costs, as the Qualified One-Way Costs Shifting (QOCS) provisions under the Civil Litigation (Expenses and Group Proceedings) (Scotland) Act 2018 continue to limit opportunities for costs recovery. The proposed reforms will significantly broaden the scope of gratuitous services claims by extending recovery beyond the current categories. The Scottish Government has indicated its intention to implement the Scottish Law Commission's recommendations during the current parliamentary session, albeit with no clarity on the proposed implementation dates. If enacted, the reforms are likely to increase the frequency and value of gratuitous services claims and create additional evidential issues around informal care. QOCS continues to substantially reduce costs exposure for claimants. Recent decisions have clarified that disapplication remains a high threshold to meet, reserved for exceptional circumstances. Despite the statutory requirement for a review of the QOCS provisions now being overdue, there is no indication of when it may occur. Until then, trends seen since the introduction of QOCS are expected to continue, with insurers continuing to face speculative claims.
Prescription remains a live risk for construction professionals in Scotland despite reforms
Recent decisions indicate that prescription remains a live risk, as statutory reform intended to ease the current uncertainty may have had a more limited practical effect than expected. Construction professionals and their insurers should continue to adopt a cautious approach to potential claims. The Court of Session's decision in the cases of Ogilvie Construction Ltd v M1 Re Glasgow Ltd and Ogilvie Construction Ltd v Leach Rhodes Walker Ltd was the first judicial consideration of the Prescription (Scotland) Act 2018. The outcomes suggested that the reforms may not have provided the protection many anticipated. The court held that the five-year prescriptive period began when the pursuer incurred the cost of remedial works, even though it did not know those costs had been incurred as a result of any wrongdoing. In reaching that conclusion, the court emphasised that the concept of "loss, injury or damage" remains unchanged from the previous regime and does not require knowledge of a wrong. As a result, all claims were held to be time-barred. The judgment reinforces the importance of early investigation of issues, along with careful record-keeping.
AI governance will reshape professional indemnity risk for Scottish firms
The Scottish professional services market will see increased deployment of generative and agentic AI, generating the need for an increasingly sophisticated professional indemnity (PI) insurance and regulatory response. Compared with many other jurisdictions, a relatively large proportion of Scotland's professional services sector consists of small and medium-sized independent firms that are not particularly well resourced. These smaller firms will need to consider how the productivity benefits of AI can be realised, but not at the expense of appropriate governance and risk controls. This will create the need for a stronger focus on AI governance, rather than AI itself. Firms that can demonstrate controlled and auditable use of AI, including strong cyber security and effective supervision, are likely to enjoy a competitive advantage. Those firms that treat AI as merely another useful software product, or as one that does not require enhanced safeguards, risk encountering regulatory issues and increasing difficulty in securing PI cover for any of their work that is heavily AI-assisted. From a PI insurance perspective, the first significant Scottish claim arising directly from negligent AI-assisted professional advice, and the market reaction to it, may well prove more influential than any forthcoming legislative developments.
Regulation of non-surgical cosmetic procedures will reshape insurer exposure in Scotland
In light of increased regulation, there may be greater scrutiny of non-surgical cosmetic treatment providers, which could lead to an increase in claims. New legislation aimed at regulating the non-surgical cosmetic industry will shortly come into force. The Non-Surgical Procedures and Functions of Medical Reviewers (Scotland) Bill passed through the Scottish Parliament in 2026 and is expected to come into effect in September 2027. The legislation introduces a three-tier system, categorised by level of risk and invasiveness. It seeks to address a perceived lack of regulation in the industry and put patient safeguarding front and centre. There are various implications for insurers. Insurance will become mandatory, which should increase demand for specialist non-surgical cosmetic policies. The introduction of a three-tier system means that existing policies should also be scrutinised to ensure there is adequate coverage.
Scottish group proceedings set to gain momentum
Group proceedings in Scotland are expected to gain momentum in 2027. The Johnson & Johnson Baby Powder litigation that has attracted considerable attention in England is subject to a parallel action commenced in Scotland. This should be viewed as part of a wider trend rather than a standalone development. The case demonstrates that Scotland's group proceedings regime will become an increasingly viable mechanism for pursuing large-scale product liability, consumer and environmental claims. The statutory framework introduced in 2018 has created a platform capable of supporting more ambitious group proceedings. Claimant firms and litigation funders are becoming increasingly familiar and comfortable with the procedure. Although Scotland is unlikely to experience growth in claims akin to other jurisdictions, the direction of travel is clear. Awareness of group proceedings will grow, particularly if actions are pursued successfully. Insurers should anticipate a broader range of coordinated claims and a continued expansion of group proceedings north of the border in the coming year.