Informed Insurance

The home of thought leadership by

Informed Insurance

Predictions
Or
Or
Regulation

Prediction: Prescription remains a live risk for construction professionals in Scotland despite reforms

Regulation
Construction and Engineering
Scotland
LinkedIn Email Share this prediction
Prediction

Recent decisions indicate that prescription remains a live risk, as statutory reform intended to ease the current uncertainty may have had a more limited practical effect than expected. Construction professionals and their insurers should continue to adopt a cautious approach to potential claims. The Court of Session's decision in the cases of Ogilvie Construction Ltd v M1 Re Glasgow Ltd and Ogilvie Construction Ltd v Leach Rhodes Walker Ltd was the first judicial consideration of the Prescription (Scotland) Act 2018. The outcomes suggested that the reforms may not have provided the protection many anticipated. The court held that the five-year prescriptive period began when the pursuer incurred the cost of remedial works, even though it did not know those costs had been incurred as a result of any wrongdoing. In reaching that conclusion, the court emphasised that the concept of "loss, injury or damage" remains unchanged from the previous regime and does not require knowledge of a wrong. As a result, all claims were held to be time-barred. The judgment reinforces the importance of early investigation of issues, along with careful record-keeping.

Back to Regulation