A surge in AI-generated data subject access requests (DSARs) and data protection complaints is currently driving organisations to reconsider their approach to managing these requests. AI tools have made it easier than ever for data subjects to generate detailed complaints, DSARs and follow-up correspondence, often referred to as ‘agentic flooding’. Organisations are increasingly facing lengthy and disproportionate submissions, large volumes of information to review and near-instantaneous data subject responses, some of which are speculative, unsupported or based on misunderstandings or misapplications of data protection law. As the administrative and financial burdens on organisations grow, they are likely to push back more readily. Rather than engaging with every assertion and request, organisations will concentrate on scoping and proportionality, make greater use of available exemptions and challenge unreasonable demands where appropriate. The result will be a shift from simply responding to complaints and DSARs as received towards actively managing and triaging them in order to seek resolution of the true underlying issue.